Why Europe Needs a Shared Framework for Next-Generation Risk Assessment
The price of fragmented risk assessment in Europe
Europe regulates thousands of chemicals, yet the methods used to judge their safety still rely heavily on animal testing, single-substance thinking and national interpretations. That fragmentation creates delays, duplicated work and uncertainty for industry and citizens alike. A substance can be evaluated differently depending on which authority, which dossier and which era of science is applied.

The ASPIS cluster was created to confront this problem directly. It pools three H2020 projects into a single €60M effort to modernise how chemical safety is judged. Rather than treating each project as an isolated research exercise, ASPIS builds one shared scientific platform for next-generation risk assessment. The ambition is not incremental improvement but a structural shift in how evidence is produced, exchanged and trusted.
What next-generation risk assessment actually means
Next-generation risk assessment moves away from default assumptions and towards mechanism-based, exposure-driven and data-rich evaluation. It asks not only whether a chemical is hazardous, but whether real people, in real conditions, are actually exposed at levels that matter. This requires new approach methodologies, or NAMs, that combine in vitro assays, computational toxicology, omics and human-relevant models.
ASPIS concentrates this work across three connected projects. Together they cover the pipeline from chemical characterisation to regulatory decision support. The cluster functions as a common infrastructure, so methods developed in one project can be validated, reused and scaled across the others. This is how a €60M investment becomes more than the sum of its parts.
- Shared data standards and interoperable tools across all three projects.
- Human-relevant test methods that reduce reliance on animal studies.
- Regulatory-ready outputs designed for EFSA, ECHA and national agencies.
Why a shared framework beats isolated projects
Chemical safety is a cross-border issue. A chemical produced in one member state can enter supply chains, food systems and environments across the entire union. If assessment methods differ, the internal market fragments and public trust erodes. A shared framework gives regulators a common scientific language and gives companies a predictable pathway to compliance.
The alternative is costly. Duplicated testing wastes resources, slows innovation and keeps questionable substances on the market longer than necessary. ASPIS argues that coordination is not bureaucracy but efficiency. The cluster's structure allows faster peer review, transparent data sharing and consistent quality criteria.
- Define common problem formulations and assessment questions.
- Develop and cross-validate new approach methodologies.
- Integrate exposure, hazard and omics data into decision frameworks.
- Deliver guidance that regulators can adopt in practice.
Building trust through transparency and training
Science alone does not change regulation. People do. ASPIS invests in training, open publications and dialogue with stakeholders so that new methods are understood rather than resisted. Regulators need confidence that a non-animal method is protective. Industry needs clarity on what evidence will be accepted. Civil society needs assurance that safety has not been traded for speed.
"A shared framework turns three projects into one credible voice for safer chemicals in Europe."
That voice matters internationally. If Europe establishes a coherent next-generation framework, it can influence global standards rather than follow them. The ASPIS cluster is therefore both a scientific programme and a strategic bet on European regulatory leadership.
From research cluster to regulatory practice
The final test of ASPIS is adoption. Publishing methods is necessary but not sufficient. The cluster must translate its outputs into templates, case studies and validation reports that fit existing legal frameworks such as REACH and food safety legislation. That translation work is embedded in the €60M plan, not added at the end.
| Challenge | Fragmented approach | ASPIS shared framework |
|---|---|---|
| Data standards | Incompatible formats | Common interoperability layer |
| Method validation | Repeated in isolation | Cross-project validation |
| Regulatory uptake | Slow and uneven | Co-designed guidance |
Europe needs a shared framework because chemical safety is too important to be left to disconnected efforts. The ASPIS cluster shows what coordinated, well-funded science can achieve: methods that are faster, more human-relevant and more trustworthy. The next step is for regulators, industry and researchers to use that framework together.
